What are your wackiest ideas for a “universal” controller layout that would appeal to the fans of the Xbox, Nintendo, and PS layouts? You certainly can’t pick one of the three, that would be lazy and frankly unfair for the other two layouts. It’s got to be something that everyone agrees on, something different!
I’ve got a few ideas: NSEW (the cardinal directions), RGBA (colours, also transparent button could be cool…), or maybe CMYK (printer ink colours for ease of printing)
What are your ideas for the universal controller layout?
I know OP’s rules say no picking one of the three already, but these are such good points I can’t help but agree. I’m also biased from years of using a PlayStation controller. Even though I haven’t owned a PS console since PS2, I’ve still been using the PS4 & 5 controllers for PC gaming.
I think legibility and avoiding overloading symbols is top priority and the PlayStation glyphs achieve this admirably. On a pettier note, I’ve never liked seeing a prompt with a big, red B button pop up on screen telling me to do something, it’s very immersion breaking. While the PlayStation prompts aren’t exactly diegetic themselves, they’re at least less non-diegetic I guess, if that makes sense?
I won’t argue symmetry vs. non-symmetry of control sticks as I don’t really think there’s a correct answer here, it’s very preferential. I obviously prefer the symmetric, but I think there’s a reason the DualShock has undergone only minor changes since it was first introduced in check notes 1997?! JFC, that’s almost 30 years …
That’s immersion 🅱️reaking, lol.
I vouch for symmetry, or rather important buttons not being placed on the bottom. Active movements and especially button presses, e.g. in QTEs or multiple menus, are rather uncomfortable there, while sticks employ a different and less demanding moveset of slightly tilting them to the side. I don’t see a reason why it’s assymetrical on Xbox and I feel it’s really dumb in autonomous Joycons with Nintendo party games when they should be completely interchangeable when shared between casual gaming persons.